Best Cookie Sheets

Do you wonder why your cookies never come out perfectly? You go to all the effort of mixing a great cookie dough and they either stick to the pan or crumble. It can be extremely frustrating. If this has happened to you, we have the solution.

Most people have bent and battered cookie sheets in the cupboard. They start to lose shape and the coating wears off. It is important to invest in quality cookie sheets if you want good results. Without a decent cookie sheet, the cookies will brown unevenly and stick to the sheet.

Fortunately, they are reasonable to replace. With so many options to choose from, it can be quite bewildering. We read countless reviews and comments from customers to narrow down the best of the best cookie sheets.

Here they are:

Nordic Ware Bakers Half Sheet

For a well-priced hard working cookie sheet, the Nordic Ware range is hard to beat. The Bakers Half Sheet is extremely reasonable, It works well and will last a long time with a bit of care.

It is a solidly built, American made, uncoated aluminum baking sheet. It will not twist and warp even under extreme heat. It is made from 18-gauge, top-quality aluminum to keep it from bending or warping. It has large edger with a good rim to prevent spills.

The surface is nonstick but you can use a silicone mat or parchment should you wish. Cookies cook and brown evenly and to the center. The cookies do not stick making the pan a breeze to clean. One of the best aspects of this product is the amazingly low price.

Nordic Ware is a well-established company known for quality products. This cookie pan is made in the USA. It is practical and durable for perfect cookies every time.

Wilton Recipe Right Non-stick Cookie Sheet Set, 2-Piece

Wilton also has a long history of making outstanding bakeware. These baking sheets are no exception and are a pleasure to work with. They are well-made from quality steel and they have a good non-stick coating. This makes them great to work with and super easy to clean.

This deal gives you two cookie sheets measuring:

5.25 x 10.25 x .75 in. (38.7 x 26 x 1.9 cm)
17.25 x 11.5 x 1 in. (43.8 x 29.2 x 22.5 cm)

The pans are versatile and can be used for a range of things from cookies to pizza. They can be cleaned in the dishwasher but it is best to just wash them with warm water and soap. Fortunately, this is easy and will ensure the non-stick surface lasts for many years. The set comes with a 5-year limited warranty

The Wilton cookie sheets are top sellers and received many positive reviews from happy customers. While the non-stick finish will not last forever, they are well priced and will give you many years of happy successful baking.

AirBake Natural 2 Pack Cookie Sheet Set

Yet another well known and highly respected brand, AirBake, bring you the amazing “original insulated bakeware”. This 2 pack of cookie sheets is entirely made from high-grade aluminum and will not rust. It also has great non-stick properties and will not rust. AirBake is confident in their product and this is demonstrated by the 10-year warranty that comes with these cookie sheets. You will get a 14-inch and a 16-inch tray.

Two sheets of heavy-duty aluminum are separated by a pillow of air. This air insulation helps to prevent burning by stopping the top sheet from getting too hot. Baking time is reduced by about 15-percent thanks to the micro-dome technology. Cookies or other baking will be able to brown evenly and cook through with a very low risk of burning The bottom layer stops the direct heat from getting through.

The AirBake Natural cookie sheets are easy to clean. Follow instructions for care and cleaning and these will last you many years.

These versatile cookie sheets are great for other baking too and are perfect for vegetables and make perfect crispy pizza. It has a rimless design so is not ideal for small items but this does make it easier to slide cookies or other baking off.

These cookie sheets are very popular and highly rated.

USA Pan Bakeware Half Sheet Pan

These are among the top selling and most loved cookie sheets available. They are made from heavy-duty aluminized steel. Part of their appeal is their durability and lifetime warranty. Not bad for a cookie sheet.
The sheets use a unique patented non-stick coating that is silicone based. This provides an effective and long-lasting non-stick coating. It has a corrugated surface which is rather unusual in a baking tray but also extremely effective. It allows for good heat distribution and even baking.

Final thoughts on Cookie Sheets

Consider that these top quality baking sheets are all super affordable, you owe it to yourself to stop working with old scratched cookie sheets and invest in a new one. It will make your baking enjoyable and ensure excellent results.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.